An engagement ring is one of the most personal pieces of jewelry you will ever wear, so why settle for something off-the-shelf? Creating a custom piece allows you to craft a ring that reflects your personal style, story, and values. At Page Sargisson, we love bringing custom designs to life through a simple, transparent process focused on exceptional craftsmanship and ethical sourcing.
Whether you are starting from scratch, repurposing a cherished heirloom stone, or seeking responsibly sourced gemstones, here is your complete guide to our custom engagement ring process in New York City.
Step 1: The Design Consultation (In-Person or Virtual)
Every custom journey begins with a conversation. We offer flexible design consultations so you can work with us in the way that best fits your lifestyle and schedule:
- In-Person Studio Visits: Meet with us at our Brooklyn or Upper East Side locations to view samples, explore ring setting customization, and discuss your design ideas up close.
- Virtual Consultations: If you are based outside New York City or prefer meeting remotely, we conduct virtual meetings online to share sketches, gemstone options, and concept ideas seamlessly.
During the consultation, we explore your aesthetic vision, budget, and daily lifestyle requirements to ensure the finished piece is both stunning and durable for a lifetime of wear.
Step 2: Stone Sourcing & Choosing Your Center Gemstone
The center stone defines the personality of your ring. We offer several thoughtfully curated options to align with your personal aesthetic and commitment to sustainability.
Using Family Diamonds and Heirloom Stones
If you have an inherited piece or family diamond, we love resetting vintage stones into fresh, modern designs that you will be excited to wear every day. Giving family diamonds a second life preserves deep sentimental value while creating a new modern legacy.
Important Note on Certifications and Appraisals: We offer GIA certification assistance for family stones upon request. However, please note that Page Sargisson does not perform appraisals. We strongly recommend having an independent appraisal completed before resetting any significant diamond.
Antique & Repurposed Vintage Diamonds
We prioritize antique and repurposed vintage diamonds whenever possible. These stones possess a distinctive warmth, historic charm, and a minimal environmental impact. We provide GIA or similar certification on all of our Engagement Ring center stones.
Lab-Grown Diamonds
For clients looking for modern diamond options with exceptional clarity and brilliance, we source high-quality lab-grown diamonds upon request.
Responsibly Sourced Sapphires
If you prefer a vibrant pop of color, our sapphire selection offers extraordinary richness. We maintain long-standing relationships with trusted vendors who uphold strict standards for quality and ethical sourcing. Our sapphires are exclusively natural or heat-treated, and we avoid stones that have undergone additional chemical treatments.
Step 3: Sustainable Metals & Local NYC Production
Craftsmanship and local production are central to our philosophy of sustainable jewelry in NYC. Every stage of our manufacturing process honors local artisan craftsmanship:
- Recycled Metals: All of our castings are created using recycled gold and platinum, helping minimize environmental impact and lower our carbon footprint.
- Local NYC Craftsmanship: Both casting and stone setting are completed locally in New York City by expert bench jewelers, guaranteeing rigorous quality control at every step.
Important Considerations: Involved vs. Surprise Proposals
Because custom jewelry is handcrafted to your exact specifications, all custom pieces are final sale. Considering whether the wearer will be part of the design journey helps ensure a seamless experience.
When the Wearer Is Involved in the Design
When the person who will be wearing the ring participates in the custom process, it guarantees that all aesthetic choices and practical daily wear concerns are addressed upfront. Crucially, it also allows us to record an accurate ring size from the start—an essential detail for intricate settings or eternity styles.
Planning a Surprise Proposal
If surprise is essential to your proposal plans, we are fully equipped to accommodate custom requests. When working without the recipient's direct input, we guide you toward specific design approaches:
- Resizable Styles: We suggest ring designs and band structures that can easily be adjusted for size after the proposal.
- Versatile Wedding Band Compatibility: We design the center setting so that it comfortably accommodates a wide variety of handmade wedding bands.
- Post-Proposal Adjustments: While custom pieces are final sale, we are happy to adjust the sizing and refine the metal finish on these pieces after you pop the question.
Begin Your Custom Journey with Page Sargisson
Designing a custom engagement ring should feel inspiring, collaborative, and straightforward. From selecting ethical center stones to finalizing hand-carved gold textures, we are dedicated to crafting a ring you will cherish forever.
Ready to bring your vision to life? Explore our Custom Gallery for inspiration, or book a consultation with our team today.
